Run this checklist on a finished draft. Every "no" is a note, not a failure — it's the rewrite telling you where it lives.
The mantras
- [ ] Can I write each main character's Deep Mantra in one plain sentence — without grading it as good or bad, smart or stupid? (If I'm judging it, I haven't found it; I've found a flaw.)
- [ ] Did each Deep Mantra build something real before it cost anything? (A mantra that only ever hurt them isn't deep. It's a wound with good PR.)
- [ ] Does each Surface Mantra have both halves — why they do what they do, and why they don't do what they don't?
The pressure
- [ ] Is there a Challenge Mantra at work — an influence the character has to experience, not an argument they can win — carrying the alternative mantra into their life?
- [ ] Does the story start by leaving the Deep Mantra alone? (Early scenes should read like life, not like a threat. The pressure arrives sideways.)
- [ ] Can I name the Crucible test in every scene — and does each test cost more than the one before?
- [ ] Which scenes have no test? For each: cut it, merge it, or give it a price.
The dots
- [ ] Am I connecting the dots for the reader — explaining what a character's behavior means — instead of leaving the dots apart and trusting them? (Name the mantra in your notes. Almost never on the page.)
- [ ] In the Rupture, does the character do — or nearly do — the thing their negative space says they'd never do?
- [ ] At the Verdict, is the bill presented in full — and do they pay it with their eyes open, whichever way they choose?